The pitfalls of analyzing cultures through the perspectives of etmic and etic

There was no page number for the Abu Lughod citation, and it is not at all clear that she wrote anything about "emic" and "etic.

Analogously to the way that a phonetic transcription is thought to be "closer to reality" than a phonemic interpretation of the soundwaves. The personal tension I felt was due to the realization that if younger LGBQ individuals are growing up in a more accepting world and, consequently, no longer feel a desire or need to fully connect with and immerse themselves in the LGBQ culture, it is quite possible that certain aspects of what it means to be LGBQ could be lost.

Even the use of video or tape recordings of social behavior To that end, I utilized life history methods within a multiple case study and co-authored comprehensive accounts of the lived experiences of six students who self-identified as LGBQ.

Consequently, selectivity may occur during the analysis of qualitative data, whether intentional or not, due to the preconceived categories and schema that a researcher employs to assign meaning YIN, Identifying these factors was significant since many individuals within this marginalized group fail to complete a bachelor's degree.

In fact, both emic and etic together comprise methodological tools Nattiez refers to but only in relation to etic. What is the relationship between cultural norms, values, and attitudes, on the one hand, and the manifestation of the behavior disorders and their treatments on the other hand.

What can we do to deal with these differences. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies, 50, As I have explained in greater detail OLIVE,five of the six young individuals in my study never experienced what could clearly be defined as a stage of pride, nor had they gone through a period of time during which they experienced an "us versus them" mentality toward heterosexuals.

Edwards Deming and Joseph M.

Talk:Emic and etic

During my sophomore year in college, I had finally reached a point at which I was ready to reveal my homosexuality to my family and friends also referred to as "coming out". Assuming Nattiez is correct in his definition of emic, the question is, how do we know what the emic view is.

These women represented a wide range of ages, lengths of tenure, a variety of ethnicities and different sexual orientations. Alternative Lifestyles, 1, Basically, culture is the lens in which us humans learn to view, perceive, and relate to the world. Can we have a source. Just thought to mention this.

Personal characteristics such as age, gender, sexual orientation, race, and ethnicity can play a significant role in the divergence between emic and etic views on the same subject; even in cases where a real-world event is being described.

Considering the amount of trust these women had placed in me, I did not feel comfortable with this option. As such, a participatory approach to the data analysis process can be especially useful in studies dealing with marginalized populations.

During my sophomore year in college, I had finally reached a point at which I was ready to reveal my homosexuality to my family and friends also referred to as "coming out".

Emic & Etic Approaches in International Research

Experience and meaning in the life-course narrative of an urban working-class man. Experience and meaning in the life-course narrative of an urban working-class man. Julian Murchison, Ethnography Essentials: If I chose not to include the information, would I not be silencing their voice and doing them a disservice.

As the use of emics and etics became more prevalent, so did the confusion regarding their definitions and how their distinctions were applied.

When a researcher takes an etic approach to his or her study, he or she uses preexisting theories, hypotheses, and perspectives as constructs to see if they apply to an alternate setting or culture. However, when a study was conducted in South Africa using the F-Scale, Pettigrew and Friedman [9] results did not predict any anti-Black prejudices.

In qualitative research, the divergence between emic and etic perspectives is now perceived to be an opportunity rather than a limitation. Life history research in educational settings: PIKE derived the term "etic" from the suffix of the word phonetic which pertains to the study of sounds which are universally used in human language—specifically, the function of sounds within a language regardless of their meanings.

However, as qualitative researchers, we owe it to our participants to strive for as near a perfect balance as is possible between the emic and etic perspectives. Introduction The purpose of the original study which serves as the foundation for this article was to identify the key factors in a lesbian, gay, bisexual, and queer LGBQ person's life history which enabled him or her to persist through higher education and successfully obtain an undergraduate degree OLIVE, The principle sources in the article, Pike and Goodenough, are from books published by major presses.

Their history in sociology and anthropology. As a scholar and researcher, I experienced tension due to the fact that, in some ways, I was sent back to the proverbial drawing board in order to adequately capture, understand, and convey the coming out processes of my participants.

Beverly Peters has more than twenty years of experience teaching, conducting qualitative research, and managing community development, microcredit, infrastructure, and democratization projects in several countries in Africa.

We most often use the emic and the etic in conjunction with each other. A study in the sociology of homosexual liberation. The Journal of Sex Research, 12. etic and emic, that these terms have reached far into other disciplines and have become much more then Pike could have ever anticipated: “various uses of the terms may be fond in journals of psychology, psychiatry, sociology, folklore, semiotics, philology, medicine.

Situated Learning and Ethnography of Communication in Cross-Cultural Management Education YUNXIA ZHU have demonstrated through their work the value of the emic analytic approach. For example, Klein-berg () taught the rich meanings of culture ries and nuanced practices of cultures.

According to Pike (), the etic approach. An emic approach might be good for studying one culture in detail to learn how they perceive, act, or experience a product or service.

On the other hand, an etic approach might be valuable when attempting to compare one or two characteristics across multiple cultures such as the use of make-up products or shoe purchasing behaviors.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of an emic analysis?

What is Emic and Etic Perspectives in Multicultural Counseling?

What are the advantages and disadvantages of an etic analysis? Best answer.

Emic and etic

Get this answer with Chegg Study View this answer. Previous question Next question.

Bevor Sie fortfahren...

Need an extra hand? Browse hundreds of Anthropology tutors. The emic and etic perspectives have to do with viewpoint.

Emic means from the perspective of an insider, etic means from the perspective of an objective observer. Ideally, ethnographies should make use of both perspectives: emic during vignettes or examples of a cultural practice, etic during the analysis of those cultural practices.

Cock fighting is a perfect example of an emic study cultural context, cocks "masculinity" bestial nature of mythology semiotic analysis (metaphors, signs, processes) symbolic meaning.

The pitfalls of analyzing cultures through the perspectives of etmic and etic
Rated 0/5 based on 88 review